| 2024 | |
|---|---|
| Owen Hood | Heidelberg University |
| Owen Wolfenberger | Hiram College |
| 2023 | |
|---|---|
| Russ Wight | Otterbein University |
| Brody Shrimplin | Mount Vernon Nazarene University |
| Jonathan Spiess | Marshall University |
| Hudson Wesney | Notre Dame College |
| Gabe Miller | Notre Dame College |
| Sawyer Benschoter | Notre Dame College |
| Robert Martin | Ohio Wesleyan University |
| Tyler Von Bargen | Ohio Dominican University |
| 2022 | |
|---|---|
| DuShaun Tucker | Hocking College |
| Mitchell Trace | Muskingum University |
| Kyle Jennings | Wilmington College |
| 2019 | |
|---|---|
| DeWayne Carter | Duke University |
| Dalton Anker | Capital University |
| Chase Chaffin | Capital University |
| Tyler Dean | Hiram College |
| Tyler Ebert | Muskingum University |
| Garrett Hardy | Muskingum University |
| Aaron Kauser | Capital University |
| Vinny Pernotto | Hiram College |
| Nathan Sewell | Mount Vernon Nazarene University |
| Adam Stefanelli | Trine University |
| Kaleb Thompson | Capital University |
| 2018 | |
|---|---|
| Brian Lee | Trevecca Nazarene University |
| Ben Miller | University of Findlay |
| Grant Ogden | Capital University |
| 2017 | |
|---|---|
| Cory Brooks | Purdue University |
| Justin Fugitt | Purdue University |
| Will Davis | Ohio Northern University |
| Austin Trace | Youngstown State University |
| Preston Stanley | Indiana Wesleyan |
| Clay Wisner | Malone University |
| Alex Shapiro | Washington and Jefferson College |
| Andy Caddas | Otterbein College |
| Kyle Boggs | Rio Grande |
| Nick Tiell | Otterbein College |
| 2016 | |
|---|---|
| Andrew Klamfoth | Ohio Christian |
| Luke Miller | Walsh |
| Lane Wisner | Mount Union |
| 2015 | |
|---|---|
| Sam Bordner | University of Louisville |
| Hunter Littlejohn | Indiana University |
| Chase Antle | Bowling Green State University |
| Joshua Shapiro | Marshall University |
| Zach Dahman | Wilmington College |
| Derek Herd | University of Findlay |
| JD Miller | Ohio Dominican |
| Nick Buchanon | Florida Southern |
| Griffin Menke | University of Findlay |
| Luke Nees | West Liberty University |
| Jared Wilson | Clark State |
| Tommy Ryan | Ohio Wesleyan |
| Drew Elliot | Wittenberg University |
| Tanner Gaerke | Washington and Jefferson College |
| 2014 | |
|---|---|
| Tommy Parsons | Adrian College |
| Ryan Curtis | Ashland University |
| Jacob Miller | Heidelberg College |